CDs June 2017 (1)

JUDITH BINGHAM – ORGAN WORKS
Stephen Farr, organs of St Edmundsbury Cathedral, St Albans Cathedral & Trinity College, Cambridge
RESONUS RES10191 (2 CDs) 69’13 & 53’49
This bumper collection of recent works by Judith Bingham is a very welcome addition to Resonus’ catalogue and should help to make these works more widely known and appreciated. The composer uses a range of starting points and influences to construct music on a variety of themes – from the liturgical (Missa brevis ‘Vidantes Stellam’) to precious stones (The Everlasting Crown– the longest work here) and botany (The Linnaeus Garden) – an organ duet. The final work included here is Tableaux Vivants for harpsichord. The scope of these works as well as the fine playing from Stephen Farr on a variety of instruments makes this a very useful and enjoyable collection.

 

POLYPHONIA IN EXCELSIS – Sacred music by CLAUDIO DALL’ALBERO
Choir of Sydney Sussex College, Cambridge, David Skinner (director)
Jim Cooper, Laurence Carden & Stephen Farr, organists
RESONUS RES10190  72’39

This very enjoyable CD brings together a number of works by the contemporary composer Claudio Dall’ Albero in excellent performances. Two pieces were written specifically for the Sydney Sussex Choir. The organ solo Trittico di Cantabrigia was composed for this recording with each movement performed by a different organist. These works link the generations who have sung of their faith, drawing on earlier forms of music, such as the Missa ‘De Angelis’. A very good introduction the sound world of this composer.

HAYDN – PIANO SONATAS, Vol 6
Jean-Efflam Bavouzet, piano
CHANDOS CHAN 10942 83’26

Jean-Efflam Bavouzet gives excellent accounts of these sonatas in this latest volume in the series from Chandos. The works are Sonatas No 11, 34-36 & 43 in B flat, D, A flat, C & E flat.

Conradin Kreutzer: Septet Op62; Trio Op43
Himmelpfortgrund, Tobias Koch, fortepiano
CPO 555067-2

Not a composer who comes immediately to mind for the early part of the nineteenth century but for lovers of chamber music of the period this is a delight. Himmelpfortgrund are an original instruments group who manage to combine an authenticity of musical line to an immediacy which makes the score truly alive. There is a real sense of domestic panache to the Septet and a compelling intimacy to the Trio.

CPE Bach: Complete works for keyboard and violin
Duo Belder Kimura
RESONUS RES 10192

The two CDs cover seven sonatas plus a Fantasia and an Arioso with Variations. If the works are all rather similar in nature, there is enough variation to keep one listening throughout, and the quality of the playing is never in doubt.

JS Bach; The Art of Fugue
Ensemble L’Arte della Fuga
OEHMS OC 1854

I am among those who regard The Art of Fugue as one of the pinnacles of artistic creativity. Unfortunately this new recording does little to help convince the un-enlightened. The extensive notes argue that the work can never be considered for the organ (for which it has always seemed to me eminently suited) and harpsichord presentation is too limited. They argue that the combination here – violin, viola, cello, double-bass and bassoon – is the ideal ensemble to fully do justice to the composition. I beg to differ. The solo bassoon simply sounds out of place and while the strings are adequate the sudden introduction of the bassoon upsets the balance. As such the ear is drawn to the unexpected balance rather than absorbing the work itself.

Das Wohltemperierte Akkordeon
Mie Miki
BIS 2217

I have heard Bach on almost any combination of instruments (see above!) but had not previously heard him on the solo accordion. This cd draws on both books and, while convincingly played, still does not somehow quite ring true. Occasionally the sound is close to a harmonium, which I have sometimes heard in the past, but, much as I would like to encourage experimentation, this really does not convince.

CDs/DVDs May 2017

Ombre Amene
Gabriella di Laccio, soprano; James Akers, guitar
DRAMA MUSICA DRAMA 002

This is a fine combination of pieces which will be unknown to all but the most diligent of connoisseurs. Mauro Giuliani and Fernando Sor were writing at the turn of the nineteenth century and both are here represented by song settings and solo works for guitar. Sor’s Etude 17 is particularly pleasing but is only marginally ahead of the settings themselves. James Akers is a fine exponent of both the solo guitar items and the accompaniments.

Soprano Gabriella di Laccio is more of an acquired taste. She specialises in Baroque music, and her finely honed high soprano, with its rapid vibrato, often makes for edgy attack and a tension which is fully in keeping with the text even if it is not as mellifluous as we would expect from a more romantic approach.

First Drop
Ars Nova Copenhagen, Paul Hillier
CANTALOUPE MUSIC CA 21127

The CD opens with an unaccompanied setting of Rise up my love by Howard Skempton. It is a disarmingly welcoming introduction to a cd which ranges widely from the intensity of Gordon’s he saw a skull to a vocal arrangement of Steve Reich’s Clapping Music for voices – both superbly done. Alongside these are works by Terry Riley, David Lang and Kevin Volans.  Worth seeking out.

Verdi: Un Ballo in Maschera
Royal Opera House, Claudio Abbado
OPUS ARTE OA 1236 D

This recording dates from 1975 but I doubt if there are any currently available to match its musical impact and beauty. The production by Otto Schenk may seem dated – how often do we get sets and costumes close to those imagined by the composer? – but it still works well and if only for Placido Domingo the work is well work adding to your collection.

Rachmaninov: Rare Piano Transcriptions
Julia Severus, piano
NAXOS 8.573468

These are fascinating items. Rachmaninov was responsible for transcribing his own works – as well as laying down many of them for player pianos where we can hear the composer himself performing his own works. Here we have twenty-two pieces, plus the longer Suite in D minor which only came to light a few years ago. Julia Severus is a convincing soloist with real romantic flair.

Strauss in St Petersburg
Estonian National Symphony Orchestra, Neeme Jarvi
CHANDOS CHAN 10937

There are so many Strauss recordings to choose from, how is a new one to make an impact? Well this does, simply by bringing together works performed while Johann II was in St Petersburg. This includes a single work by Olga Smirnitskaya – Erste Liebe – if only to show that Russian composers were very aware of the Viennese influence! A fine disc and one which had an innate sense of Straussian rhythm without pulling it all over the place – as too many do these days.

Maestro Corelli’s Violins
Collegium Musicum 90, Simon Standage
CHACONNE CHAN 0818

Six concerti by six different contemporaries of Corelli , all giving a strong indication of the wealth of music still to be discovered from the early eighteenth century. Beautifully played and worth the indulgence even if you think you know the period well already.

Bruckner: Symphony No2
Mozarteumorchester, Ivor Bolton
OEHMS OC 447

This is a live recording from Salzburg made in October 2015. Bruckner regularly revised his symphonies and the second exists in at least four versions. This is the earliest, and longest, and as such represents the composer’s own approach to the work before any critics had had any influence over him. Far more rarely heard than the later symphonies, it is still a splendid work in its own right and the recording brings us the immediacy and impact of the composer’s creative genius.

Schubert: String Quartet in G major; String Quartet in C minor Quartettsatz
Doric String Quartet
CHANDOS CHAN 10931

The recording opens with the more familiar Quartettsatz in a muscular, exciting reading. The lesser known Op post 161 has an altogether different level of intensity, very much post-Beethoven in its architecture and dynamics. It is also one of the longest when given its proper length as it is here. This is a fine twin to the earlier release of the quartets based on Rosamunde and Death and the Maiden.

In the stream of life; songs by Sibelius
Gerald Finley, Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra, Edward Gardner
CHANDOS CHAN CHSA 5178

There are so many good things on this cd it is difficult to know where to start. Pohjola’s Daughter and The Oceanides are familiar but given exemplary performances. Alongside these we have the premiere recording of In the stream of life, challenging in its immediacy and even today unexpected in its intensity. With this come seven less familiar song settings and the Op42 Romance. Edward Gardner has produced some very memorable recordings with the Bergen Phil but this has to be one of the best.

Guitarra Mia; Tangos by Gardel and Piazzolla
Franz Halasz, guitar
BIS 2165

Not only does this bring the music of Carlos Gardel and Astor Piazzolla to a wider audience, with beautifully phrased performances throughout, but it leads us – for those like myself with little background in the Tango – to extensive video clips from the films Gardel made in the 1930s. Both well worth investigating.

 

CDs / DVDs April 2017

Handel: Messiah
Bach Consort Wien, Ruben Dubrovsky
NAXOS 2.110387

Interesting for those of us so used to English singers performing an essentially English composition, to hear it in a German recording. The Bach Consort Wien draw on a very different background and yet come to surprisingly familiar conclusions. If the ornamentation in places is refreshingly different the main thrust of the work is entirely – and pleasingly – conservative. Soloists are secure, even where they are obviously not singing in their first language. Ruben Dubrovsky conducts with a clear ear for Baroque temperament and the whole is entirely pleasing.

Verdi: Un Ballo in Maschera
Bayerische Staatsoper, Zubin Mehta
UNITEL 739408

This production, recorded a year ago, is set in the 1930s with a sense of inter-war decadence to it which proves convincing, enabling the disparate elements to gel in a convincing way. It is well sung throughout and was extremely well received when first seen in Vienna. It is so good these days that an unusual presentation can be released so soon after the original staging and while the singers are still very much with us for the performance to be still in the repertoire.

Wagner: Der Ring des Nibelungen
Staatskapelle Weimar, Carl St Clair
ARTHAUS 109319

It almost seems unfair to try to comment on a complete recording of The Ring within a review page such as this. There is so much one could say of this fascinating and at times infuriating interpretation that one would hope for far more. However, to sum up, the approach which Michael Schulz takes is to include the gods far more frequently and to allow late 20th century iconographic to inhabit Wagner’s world. The Valkyries march on like the Von Trapp children, the final act of Valkyrie being set in a girls’ dorm. The gods in Rheingold are eminently human, with human needs and fallibilities. The strong pro-feminist line throughout finds its fulfilment at the end of Gotterdammerung when Brunnhilde walks off with her confidant, Grane, and leaves the, newly enfranchised, women to bask in the spring rain.

Much of this is splendidly accomplished. Das Rheingold is intimate and often compellingly naturalistic. If Die Walkure has a slightly weaker Wotan it does not inhibit an excellent overall performance, with a stunning visual climax. Siegfried is let down by a weak Wanderer, thought the staging as a whole is less effective here – no forging, no dragon, no fire.

Gotterdammerung works better, with Catherin Foster a fine Brunnhilde and Norbert Schmittberg equally secure as Siegfried. The staging works here, if only because it reflects what we had come to expect and never undervalues the score.

Carl St Clair is adept at keeping the long paragraphs of the score moving effortlessly and allowing the text to cut through with ease. Worth a look and possibly worth keeping if not quite up there with some of the finest we now have.

AMERICAN VOICES
St Thomas Choir of Men & Boys, Fifth Avenue, New York
John Scott, conductor
RESONUS RES10187   74’18

This recording features some now well-established sacred choral works by American composers including Bernstein’s Chichester Psalms, Copland’s In the beginning and Barber’s Agnus Dei. Alongside these are lesser known and more recent works by Randall Thompson, Nico Muhly, Daniel Castellanos & Ned Rorem, as well as an arrangement of Deep River by Gerre Hancock. The recording beautifully captures the choir in performances of conviction and emotion. A lovely production.

KODALY & DOHNANYI – Chamber Works for Strings
Simon Smith & Clare Hayes (violins), Paul Silverthorne (viola), Katherine Jenkinson (‘cello)
RESONUS RES 10181   70’19

This is a very welcome release of lesser known but significant works for strings from the first half of the twentieth century. The performances are fresh and polished. Two pieces are by Zoltan Kodaly – Duo for Violin & Cello, Op 7 and Serenade for 2 Violins & Viola, Op 1.Erno Dohnanyi’s Serenade for String Trio, Op 10 completes the CD.

LABYRINTH – Mozart, Ligeti & Bach
Dudok kwartet, Amsterdam
RESONUS RES 10180   55’24

More music for strings makes up this CD which presents a fascinating programme with music from different eras linked together by the theme of counterpoint and labyrinth. There is a shocking but delightful juxtaposition as Mozart’s String Quartet No 14 in G major leads into String Quartet No 2 by Ligeti which features the micropolyphonic structures which he pioneered. The recording ends with a return to what we may regard as more traditional music but which in themselves are boundary-pushing compositions: four Canons by the master of musical simplicity-in-complexity, JS Bach. Highly recommended listening.

TOCCATA: TOUCHED
Alex McCartney, theorbo
VETERUM MUSICA VM015

A sublime recital of works by G G Kapsberger (c1580 – 1651). Although complex music this is a very relaxing listening experience as Alex McCartney breathes life into this ancient and mostly forgotten music. A lovely production.

HANS LEO HASSLER – Orgelwerke (Suddeutsche Orgelmeister Vol 5)
Joseph Kelemen,
Freundt organ (1642), Stiftskirche, Klosterneuburg & Gunzer organ (1609), St Martin, Gabelbach
OEHMS CLASSICS OC658   79’51

This recording presents wonderfully authentic performances matching this music to near contemporary organs. The music is played with feeling and with great variety in registration. There is a good contrast of style and structure throughout the programme which includes an Orgelmesse, chorale preludes, introits, canons and ricercares. I am left wanting to listen to further volumes in this series.

MARCO ENRICO BOSSI- Complete Organ Works Vol 12
Andrea Macinanti, organ (with Giovanni Battista Fabris, violin & Elena Perera,’ cello)
Organ of Duomo di Thiene
TACTUS TC862790 (2CDs)   59’11 & 56’07

At first glance this recording seems an unnecessary volume in a series dedicated to the works of a single composer. However, on reading the notes and listening to the music I have come to see how important this volume is! Bossi championed the music of many of these ‘Old Masters’ and by doing so breathed new life into them, cherishing the musical structures and ideas from past generations but not being afraid to develop them further and incorporate his own ideas alongside them.  The CD is an enjoyable listening experience in its own right but the value lies more in helping others to appreciate how composers draw on the legacy left before them.

Borodin: Piano Quinter in C minor; Cello Sonata in B minor;
String Quartet No2 in D major
Goldner String Quartet, Piers Lane piano
HYPERION CDA 68166

A pleasure throughout, and even more so to have the rare cello sonata in addition to more familiar works. Hyperion have done it again – filling gaps in the market and proving their choice right!

Shostakovich: Piano Concertos Nos 1 & 2; String Quartet No8 arr Giltburg
Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra, Rhys Owens, trumpet, Vasily Petrenko
NAXOS 8.573666

Boris Giltburg is a most convincing soloist for the two Shostokovich piano concertos with a lively trumpet in the first concerto from Rhys Owens. The additional pleasure here is the arrangements of two string quartets for piano solo. We have two movements from the Op68 quartet – the Waltz and Allegro – and a complete performance of the String Quartet No 8. This later was made with the permission of the Shostakovich family and proves to be a darkly defined composition which is not out of place as a solo piece.

Johan Botha
ORFEO C 906 171 B

These recordings were made in Vienna between 1997 and 2014. Johan Botha was an heroic tenor, most at home in Wagner and Strauss, both of whom are represented here, plus a fine recording of Gott, welch Dunkel hier when he appeared as Florestan in Beethoven’s Fidelio. He was seen most recently via the Met’s cinema links as Walter in Die Meistersinger which is reflected here in a live recording of the Prize Song. His untimely death last autumn robbed the opera world of a fine singer.

The excellency of hand: English viola da gamba duos
Robert Smith & Paolo Pandolfo
RESONUS RES10186

This cd is a delight throughout, bringing together 22 pieces of early music, most of which will be unknown to the majority of listeners. There are works by Christopher Simpson, John Jenkins, Simon Ives plus the gentle intervention of a single work by Robert Smith which is totally in keeping with the seventeenth century surroundings. The sheer grace and delight here speak for themselves – just hear it for yourself!

Medtner and Rachmaninov Piano Concerti
London Philharmonic Orchestra, Marc-Andre Hamelin, piano, Vladimir Jurowski
HYPERION CDA 68145

The Rachmaninov is of course very familiar and here equally well performed. The novelty is the Medtner which is far less well known and manages to keep its place surprisingly well alongside its more familiar partner. The two composers knew each other and Rachmaninov helped his younger friend who never had the same level of exposure or following. The differences are obvious even in the brief consideration of these two works. Medtner is a pianist and composes from the point of view of the soloist, while Rachmaninov’s ear is for the whole orchestra.

Max Bruch: String Quintets and String Octet
The Nash Ensemble
HYPERION CDA 68168

What is it about Octets that make them so satisfying? The great ones are out of this world and I have to include the Bruch Octet alongside them. Those who are besotted by the violin concerto – overplayed but never quite outstaying its welcome – will surely delight in this. When put alongside the two string quintets this it surely a most attractive recording.

Luigi Legnani: Works for Guitar
Raffaele Carpino, guitar
TACTUS TC 791201

I have to admit to knowing nothing of Luigi Legnani but these really are lovely works and so easy on the ear without ever being obviously populist. Working within the early part of the nineteenth century he was a friend of Rossini and both played and sang tenor as well as composing. He died almost forgotten in 1877 having composed 250 opus numbers plus a large number of unnumbered pieces, many of which are now lost. This recording should go a long way to restoring his name if only because it is a pleasure to listen to and beautifully crafted throughout.

Music for the 100 Years’ War
The Binchois Consort, Andrew Kirkman
HYPERION CDA 68170

This recording comes out of a collaboration between the Binchois Consort and the Castle Museum, Nottingham. The detailed notes include a wide range of photos of medieval alabaster carvings which reflect the music and life of the period. The notes are detailed and the translations are precise for each item. This alone makes it something of a rarity when notes can be skimped or often non-existent. To this one must note the fine recording itself and the close relationship between music, text and image. A very welcome recording of works by Alanus, Dunstable, Forest and Power plus anonymous items.

DVDs / CDs March 2017

Donizetti: Roberto Devereux
Teatro Carlo Felice, Francesco Lanzillotta
DYNAMIC 37755

We have seen more of this opera recently than probably any time in the last century and it is a worthy partner to the more familiar Anna Bolena. The production is very dark – you may need a large screen and a darkened room to pick up some of the detail – but the music is well focussed throughout and Francesco Lanzillotta keeps his forces moving swiftly. Mariella Devia is a tight-lipped monarch attempting to maintain emotional control while the world falls apart around her. All the solo parts are well taken and the chorus creep about as if terrified of what might happen next.

Tango Under The Stars
Los Angeles Philharmonic, Gustavo Dudamel
MAJOR 739608

The combination of the expertise of the Los Angeles Philharmonic and the Latin enthusiasm of Gustavo Dudamel make for a glorious evening. If the audience are not quite what one might wish for in a concert hall, the outdoor Hollywood Bowl is able to absorb the extraneous noise and the applause between movements. The central work is the 2nd Guitar Concerto by Lalo Schifrin, with Angel Romero as soloist followed by four dances from Estancia by Ginastera.

For the final four pieces by Astor Piazzolla they are joined by Tango Buenos Aires who dance with a heighted intensity and highly sensuous movements which is totally captivating.

Vaughan Williams: Job; Symphony No 9
Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra, Sir Andrew Davis
CHANDOS CHAN 5180

Job, a Masque for Dancing is heard rather than seen these days, which is a pity for this is undeniably ballet music of the finest order. The combination of Job with the 9th Symphony is telling as their composition spans almost thirty years and yet the composer’s voice is immediately obvious in both. Not that Vaughan Williams had not developed over the period, so much as his own voice always shines through with immediacy. Sir Andrew Davis’ strengths as an interpreter of English music are well known and this is another excellent example of his insights and understanding.

Schubert; Works for solo piano Vol 2
Barry Douglas
CHANDOS CHAN10933

This may only be vol 2 but already this is obviously a very fine undertaking and we can look forward to the rest of the series. Here we have the Four Impromptus Op 90 and the A major Piano Sonata D959, all late works and showing Schubert at the peak of his powers, none more so than in the final movement of the Sonata which draws on earlier works yet spins a new sense of creativity which is wholly captivating.

Franz Krommer: Symphonies 1-3
Orchestra della Svizzera italiana, Howad Griffiths
CPO 555 099-2

Krommer has all but vanished from our concert halls. Though held by many in his lifetime to be valued as highly as Haydn he rapidly went out of fashion and disappeared from public performance by the end of the nineteenth century. This is one of the strange acts of fate which seem to fall on some composers for no obvious reason. These three symphonies would grace any early romantic programme and the composer’s voice is individual enough to make for a worthy place alongside more familiar composers. The difficulty, I suspect, is that the audience will not necessarily react as enthusiastically to a name on a concert list that they do not no. a pity for these are fine pieces.

William Boyce; Symphonies
Academy of St Martin in the Fields, Sir Neville Marriner
CAPRICCIO C8006

Recorded in 1993, this is a welcome reissue of a very fine recording, full of life and energy.

Dutilleux; Symphony No 2 etc
Orchestre National de Lille, Darrell Ang
NAXOS 8.573596

Henri Dutilleux is still underrepresented in our concert halls and so this new cd goes some way towards offsetting that balance. The 2nd Symphony is extrovert in its attack and detail, with splendid tone colours. This is taken up again in the three movements of Timbres, espace, movement which was revised in 1991. The sixteen short movements of Mystere de l’instant give snatches if not outbursts of creativity, which are gone almost before they can impinge.

Beneath the Northern Star
The Orlando Consort
HYPERION CDA 68132

This is early polyphonic music stretching from the late thirteenth century to the early fifteenth. The Orlando Consort explore the way musical lines were elaborated and embellished within their liturgical settings. Early pieces are often anonymous, and even where composers are named we often know little of them except for the quality of the writing. The cd is both instructive and beautifully performed.

Brahms; complete solo piano music vol 4
Jonathan Plowright
BIS 2137

The two sets of Variations on a Theme of Paganini bookend this new collection and between them come compelling readings of the Op10 Ballades and Op119 Piano Pieces. Jonathan Plowright’s approach brings a chamber intimacy to the works which is always rewarding.

Sullivan; Songs
Mary Bevan, Ben Johnson, Ashley Riches with David Owen-Norris, piano
CHANDOS CHAN 10935(2)

I wish I could feel more enthusiastic about this collection but, though a few songs catch the ear, too many are worthy but dull. Sullivan may have hated the fact that his popularity stemmed from his work with Gilbert but there is little here to match anything from Yeomen of the Guard or Mikado.

British Tone Poems Vol 1
BBC National Orchestra of Wales, Ramon Gamba
CHANDOS 10939

It is surprising how much music by familiar names is still so little known. Here we have a fine collection of British tone poems none of which I can recall ever hearing live. Ivor Gurney’s A Gloucestershire Rhapsody is Elgarian in feel but none the worse for that. Frederick Austin’s Spring and William Alwyn’s Blackdown  most capture the imagination, while Henry Balfour Gardiner’s moving A Berkshire Idyll receives its premiere recording. With Vaughan William’s The Solent to conclude the recording this is a very valuable addition to our understanding of less familiar repertoire.

CDs February 2017

CPE BACH – SOLO KEYBOARD MUSIC, Vol 32
Miklos Spanyi (Tangent piano)
BIS 2205 78’54

This massive survey of CPE Bach’s keyboard music continues with the remaining pieces from the “fur Kenner & Liebbaber” collections featured in Vol 31. That recording was made on a clavichord. Here Miklos Spanyi produces some delightfully light and characterful sounds from a Tangent piano, a variant of the Fortepiano. There is a satisfying symmetry to the programme which alternates between a Sonata and a Rondo, three of each in total. An enjoyable stand-alone disc as well as a welcome expansion of this series.

CARL CZERNY – ORGAN MUSIC
Ian Quinn(organ),  Miller Chapel, Princeton Theological Seminary, Princeton, NJ, USA
NAXOS 8.573425 75’11

For many of us the name of this composer brings back memories of early piano lessons with books of his studies. I was unaware that Czerny had also composed for the organ. This is an enjoyable and interesting collection consisting of a substantial Prelude & Fugue in A minor, and two sets of pieces – 20 Short Voluntaries for organ with obbligato pedal and 12 Introductory or Intermediate Voluntaries.
The style is typical of the 19th Century and some of the voluntaries were apparently intended for the English market.

JOHANN PACHELBEL – COMPLETE ORGAN WORKS II
Jurgen Essi, Michael Belotti, James David Christie (organs )
Stephanskirche, Simmern   &  Kilianskirche, Bedheim
CPO 777 557-2  (2CDs) 117’21

As is the case with so many composers there is a wealth of organ music from the pen of Johann Pachelbel that is rarely heard today. In this second volume of the complete organ works we have Christmas music from Das Kirchenjahr  together with Psalmlieder III. As well as being a useful reference resource this collection is very suited to listening to as a programme in its own right. There are intricate passages, beautiful sustained lines and delicate and colourful registrations to be found as well as full-blooded movements such as the opening Toccata. The mix of organists and organists gives added interest to this release.

JAKOB PRAETORIUS / PAUL SIEFERT– COMPLETE ORGAN WORKS
Friedhelm Flamme (organ)
St Laurentius-kirche, Langwarden & Martin-Luther-Kirche, Schonhagen
CPO 777 959-2 (2 CDs) 138’48

Although it gives no indication on the sleeve the booklet states that this is Vol 14 of Organ Works of the North German Baroque. So much of this vast period of organ composition stands to be rediscovered. Here we hear the 11 pieces that remain by Praetorius and 17 by Siefert. There is also an extended chorale prelude by Jakob Kortkamp. A particularly enjoyable performance is to eb found at track 6 on the 2nd CD,  Seifert’s Puer natusin Bethlehem – beginning with a particularly bombastic theme and followed by much more delicate registration. An interesting collection but maybe not one to be listened to in one sitting.

KENNETH LEIGHTON – COMPLETE ORGAN WORKS
Stephen Farr (organ), Chloe Hanslip (violin), Nicky Spence (tenor)
Organs of St Giles’ Cathedral, Edinburgh, Symphony Hall, Birmingham & St Paul’s, Knightsbridge
RESONUS RES10178 (3 CDs) 78’31, 53’16, 76’19

This comprehensive production is a further sign of Resonus’ commitment to producing significant recordings of lesser known music. Whilst Kenneth Leighton’s name is known in some circles recordings of his music are not always easy to come by, and so this set of the complete organ works is a very welcome release. The Missa de Gloria is one of the more substantial works presented here, together with Prelude, Scherzo & Passacaglia and Et Ressurexit (Theme, Fantasy & Fugue). More melodic in nature are the opening Six Fantasies on Hymn Tunes, most based on familiar hymn repertoire. Possibly the best known of the shorter works is  Paean, a wonderfully celebratory burst. As well as all the solo organ compositions this set also includes These are the wonders, for organ and tenor and Fantasy on a chorale “Es ist genug”  for organ and violin – an interesting and seldom heard combination.  An extended set of Improvisations “De profundis” for solo harpsichord completes the final disc. Stephen Farr gives wonderful performances throughout. Once again a variety of organs adds interest to what is already a very valuable collection. Highly recommended.

O SING UNTO THE LORD – SACRED MUSIC BY HENRY PURCELL
St Thomas Choir of Men & Boys, Fifth Avenue, New York, USA
Concert Royal
John Scott (conductor)
RESONUS RES 10184 54’03
GABRIEL FAURE – REQUIEM
St Thomas Choir of Men & Boys, Fifth Avenue, New York, USA
Orchestra of St Luke’s
John Scott (conductor)
RESONUS RES 10174 58’14

These two CDs of more mainstream repertoire are also released by Resonus, continuing their output of fine recordings of the Choir of St Thomas, Fifth Avenue, under the leadership of the late John Scott. Both CDs make for repeated listening. The Faure CD also includes his other popular sacred works –  Messe Basse, Ave verum corpus, Tantum ergo and Cantique de Jean Racine.

CLASSICAL VIENNA – Music for Guitar & Piano
James Akers (romantic guitar), Gary Branch (fortepiano)
RESONUS RES 10182 67’47

This is an interesting release from a historic angle – recreating the sound world of a bygone age combining the sounds of an 1826 fortepiano with guitar. This is one of the last recordings to be made at Finchcocks, now sadly no more. The programme is varied, including compositions by Mauro Giulani and Ferdinando carulli amongst others. The duo work well together and in fine solo performances. However, on a personal note, I’m just not that keen on the sound of the fortepiano. I am sure others will relish it.

SP

CDs/DVDs January 2017

Bruckner: Symphony No 4
UNITEL 732508
Bruckner: Symphony No 6
UNITEL 738208
Staatskapelle Dresden, Christian Thielemann

This is proving to be an excellent series, and if, as promised, it goes on to include the even rarer early symphonies it will prove to be invaluable. If the Fourth is more conventional in approach, its tonal qualities and masterly construction of long paragraphs is continually rewarding. The Sixth is another matter. Very rarely heard live, its starkly different tonal palette compared with his other symphonies is all the more compelling. It is surely more than the fact that the composer had been on an extended holiday before he composed the work. There is an openness of texture and a lightness of touch we find nowhere else. Perhaps it is time some of our own orchestras explored its very eal riches.

 

Joseph Beer: Polnische Hochzeit
Gartnerplatz Chorus and Munich Radio Symphony Orchestra, Ulf Schirmer
CPO 555 059-2

Anyone who enjoys Lehar will be immediately attracted to this operetta from a composer who spanned virtually the whole of the twentieth century. The Polish Wedding was first seen in 1937, shortly after Lehar’s final work Giuditta. The story line may be conventional but the music has an unexpected freshness and vitality, aided I am sure by the recently reworked orchestral parts. Worth investigating.

 

Music from a Higher Sphere
Mahler: Symphony No 8
Arranged for organ and chorus by David Briggs
PRO ORGANO CD 7276

I have enjoyed David Briggs earlier forays into Mahler, and felt the arrangement of the Fifth Symphony was particularly impressive. Here I am not so sure. The Eighth relies heavily on its choral setting, where the orchestra supports and enhances the vocal line. On this occasion the organ does not seem to adequately fill out Mahler’s intentions. The acoustic in the Cathedral of St John the Divine, New York, does not help, and for much of the recording both the voices and organ seem distant. This may be a good souvenir of the live performance but it does little to enthuse this listener.

 

J P Sousa: Music for Wind Band – 16
Marine Band of the Royal Netherlands Navy, Keith Brion
NAXOS 8.559746

This is a joy to listen to throughout.  The longest section is a selection from the operetta The Charlatan alongside which are ten other pieces, all equally endearing. How Sousa was constantly able to turn out so much wonderful music is a mystery, and the longer this series continues the more pleased I shall be.

 

J S Bach; Cantatas
Iestyn Davies, Arcangelo, Jonathan Cohen
HYPERION CDA 68111

Three Cantatas – BWV 170; BWV 54; BWV82 – together with the Sinfonias from BWV 52 and 174, make this a fine collection and one which shows off Iestyn Davies continuing strengths as a counter-tenor of rare quality. These cantatas were written for boy altos rather than counter-tenor, which only goes to show the quality of voices Bach had at his disposal. The final cantata, Ich habe genug is also the most familiar, but listeners may be surprised by the sinfonia from BWV 174 which is arranged from the Third Brandenburg Concerto.

 

Rostropovich Encores
Alban Gerhardt, cello, Markus Becker, piano
HYPERION CDA 68136

A collection of encores may not seem the most obvious to issue as a single cd but given that these were pieces used by Mstislav Rostropovich puts them into an altogether different class. Alongside familiar pieces by Debussy and Rachmaninov are a number of pieces by Prokofiev as well as some by Rostropovich himself. All of which makes for an unexpectedly pleasing recording.

 

Hymnus: Music for Organ by Carson Cooman
Erik Simmons, 1787 Holzhey organ, St Peter & St Paul, Weissenau, Germany
DIVINE ART DDA 25147  66:00

Carson Cooman is a prolific composer and an organist in his own right, though here his works are performed by Erik Simmons on the fine late baroque organ in St Peter & St Paul, Weissenau. The cd is made up of a large number of short pieces, many of which were written in memory of friends or to commemorate specific individuals. As such the whole has a highly reflective character which is none the worse for that. The opening Haec Aeterna is typical of the cd as a whole, being a meditative postlude built around the Old Hundreth. Many of the pieces are in a similar vein, using familiar hymn tunes as the basis for more elaborate, though normally brief, compositions.

There are a few exceptions. Three Enigmas are just that – short pieces which explore harmonics rather than procure any narrative structure. As if to prove that he can provide more exhilarating scores, the cd concludes with a rousing Rondo Festivo.

Many of these pieces would sit comfortably within either a liturgical or concert format, and details of compositions and scores can be found on www.carsoncooman.com

CDs/DVDs December 2016

A WELLS CHRISTMAS
Wells Cathedral Choir, Matthew Owens (director), Jonathan Vaughn (organ)
RESONUS RES10176 61’54

Resonus continues to welcome well established performers to record for the label. Here Wells Cathedral Choir under the direction of Matthew Owens presents a programme of music that is often familiar but nevertheless fresh and lively. Many traditional English carols are sung in arrangements by the likes of John Rutter, Vaughan Williams, Malcolm Sargent and David Willcocks. There are also two world premiere recordings of Bob Chilcott’s work and one by Matthew Owens himself. Two organ solos are also included. The CD ends with several more secular items, a decision that will divide opinion, I am sure.

TO BETHLEHEM – Carols & Motets for Christmas
Kantorei of Kansas City, Chris Munce (director)
RESONUS RES10175 61’29

This CD combines unusual renaissance repertoire with contemporary works in a beautiful programme for unaccompanied choir. There are some arrangements of familiar material included in the newer works but mostly this is a journey of adventure and surprise.

THE CHORAL MUSIC OF COLIN MAWBY
Choir of Liverpool Metropolitan Cathedral
 Christopher McElroy (director), Richard Lea & James Luxton (organists)
PRIORY PRCD1163

Colin Mawby’s contribution to liturgical music, particularly in the Catholic Church, has been immense. In his 80th year this CD showcases a wide range of his work, presented by one of the country’s leading Catholic Cathedral choirs. This is an excellent presentation and an enjoyable CD in its own right.

THE COMPLETE ORGAN WORKS OF THOMAS TERTIUS NOBLE VOL 3
John Scott Whiteley, Organ of York Minster
PRIORY PRCD 1152

This short series concludes with another CD of excellent performances by John Scott Whiteley on the organ he knows so well. The programme begins with the longest item,Theme with variations in D flat. It also features a number of voluntaries based on hymn tunes, shorter pieces and the Solemn March in E flat minor.

SIGFRID KARG-ELERT – THE COMPLETE ORGAN WORKS VOL 13
Stefan Engels, Steinmeyer organ of Michaeliskirche, Hamburg, Germany
PRIORY PRCD 1134 71’18

This longer series reaches Vol 13. It features lesser known works – Three Pastels Op 92, Music for Organ Op 145 and the Passacaglia & Fugue on B-A-C-H Op 150.

SIR CHARLES VILLIERS STANFORD – THE COMPLETE ORGAN WORKS VOL 4
Daniel Cook, Organ of Westminster Abbey
PRIORY PRCD 1161 74’07

Daniel Cook continues his excellent survey of Stanford’s organ music on the organ he plays regularly at Westminster. Items included in this instalment include Symphony No 5 in A, Four Intermezzi and the extended Prelude & Fugue in E minor  and  Installation March (1908). Highly enjoyable.

JOHANN MICHAEL HAYDN – SERENADE IN D
Virtuosi Saxoniae, Ludwig Guttler (director)
CAPRICCIO ENCORE C8003

The liner notes give some background to the specific circumstances that this music was written for. Originally to be performed outside and in honour of a specific person the Serenade was often intended for one-off use. Sometimes, however, a new work would be created for repeated use from some of the original material. An interesting and enjoyable release.

SP

Glass; Einstein on the Beach
Lucinda Childs Dance Company, Chatelet Theatre, Paris, Michael Riesman
OPUS ARTE OA 1178D

The real challenge here is to simply let yourself relax into the dynamics of the performance. Not only is the score minimalist but so is a large amount of the stage movement. This becomes both hypnotic and absorbing as the work progresses on it slow but inevitable path. There is also a very real sense of humour in the staging which often comes unexpectedly to light. Musically it is spot on and the company is as fine vocally as it is choreographically.

Arrigo Boito: Mefistofele
Bayerisches Staatsoper, Omer Meir Wellber
UNITEL CMajor 73908

Roland Schwab sets his production in a corrupt wasteland. If heaven exists it is very much off stage, but as Rene Pape’s Mefistofele is the key to the whole work this makes a lot of sense. Boito is far better known today for his work as Verdi’s librettist, but this is a fine work, poised between Verdi himself and the developments that were to come with Puccini. He is happy to borrow ideas where they work – as with the voluptuous Verdian choruses – but the bridge passages are often very well structured and the dialogue terse and effective. Joseph Calleja may not be much of an actor but his heroic Faust is convincing. As a whole the recordings is a valuable addition.

Telemann: Advent Cantatas
Gudrun Sidone Otto
CPO 777 955-2

There is a surprising amount of variety in these cantatas for the Sundays leading up to Christmas. Soprano Gudrun Sidone Otto and baritone Ingolf Seidl shape the material with a keen sense of the dramatic and are not averse to the occasional humorous touch. The continuo ensemble brings an improvisatory touch which makes the whole a pleasure to listen to.

Mauro Giuliani; Music for Two Guitars
Jeffrey McFadden, Michael Kolk, guitars
NAXOS 8.572445

There are some CDs which give instant delight and this is certainly one of them. Mauro Giuliani was ‘perhaps the greatest guitarist who has ever lived’ and was a friend of Rossini, whose works he arranged for two guitars. We hear a number of these, including four overtures and some more domestic pieces. They are, without exception, perfect miniatures. The arrangements of the overtures, even when one knows the originals well, are entirely convincing. If you want to impress somebody this Christmas, this CD has to be an obvious choice.

BH

CDs November 2016

Handel: Messiah (arr Davis)
Toronto Symphony Orchestra and Mendelssohn Choir, Sir Andrew Davis
CHANDOS CHSA 5176(2)
Most professional performances of Messiah these days take account of baroque praxis even if they perform on modern instruments. Sir Andrew Davis here takes a very different approach, re-scoring much of the oratorio not only for modern instruments but for combinations which Handel could never have contemplated. For most of the time this works well. Use of clarinets and a more romantic sound for the continuo is easy enough on the ear. The moments which startle are those which involve unexpected percussion – the snare-drum in Thus saith the Lord and the cymbals in But who may abide – and occasionally the over-exuberance of the brass. But it is well sung throughout and for anybody wanting what passed for normal fifty years ago, this may be just the thing.

 

Wagner: Die Walkure
Honk Kong Philharmonic Orchestra, Jaap van Zweden
NAXOS 8.660394-97

I had enthused about Das Rheingold when it was issued last year and this new Die Walkure certainly lives up to expectation. First of all the acoustic is splendid, giving real clarity to the voices with a sense of space around them, and an orchestral ambience which is constantly enthralling. Stuart Skelton, surely the finest heldentenor now singing, is magnificent as Sigmund, heroic and sensitive throughout and ringingly secure in the top passages. Heidi Melton is a sensitive Sieglinde who warms and develops as the evening progresses. Falk Struckmann, himself a fine Wotan, is a suitably black Hunding. Matthias Goerne and Petra Lang are perhaps better known and live up to expectations, and there are no weaknesses among the Valkyries.

I’m really looking forward to the rest of the Cycle which could easily earn its place among the finest ever recorded. Jaap van Zweden has set the orchestra among the best in the world.

MOZART – PIANO DUETS Vol 1
Julian Perkins & Emma Abbate
RESONUS RES10172 68’04

Successful piano duet playing places particular demands on the performers and here the two pianists are working very well together. This is a programme of more substantive works written for this particular genre. As well as the Sonatas in C major, D major & Bb major the programme also includes Johann Christoph Bach’s two movement Sonata in A major. A second volume, also on period instruments,  is to follow.

JOSEPH BODIN de BOISMORTIER – 6 SONATES, Op 51
Elysium Ensemble
RESONUS RES 10171 71’24

Resonus are to be congratulated on their recent output of unusual repertoire. Here is another fascinating disc presenting these six compositions for flute and violin, published in Paris in 1734. This neglected repertoire is made to sound very fresh in these performances.

MUSIC FOR A PRUSSIAN SALON
Boxwood & Brass
RESONUS RES 10177 72’53

The five piece period woodwind and brass ensemble make a lovely sound, bringing this 18th/ early 19th Century music to life in a way that is entertaining and very accessible. Franz Tausch’s XIII Pieces en Quatuor, Op 22 for 2 clarinets, horn & bassoon are presented in two suites which bookend the performance. Sandwiched between these are Johann Stamitz’ Three Quartets for clarinets & horns and Concert-Trio for clarinet, horn & bassoon by Bernhard Henrik Crusell.

RAVEL & SAINT-SAENS PIANO TRIOS
Fidelio Trio
RESONUS RES10173 59’58

This is the first recording by the Fidelio Trio on the Resonus label. Saint-Saens’ Piano Trio No 2 in E minor is paired here with Ravel’s only Piano Trio. A very enjoyable chamber music recital.

BEETHOVEN PIANO SONATAS Opp 31, 78, 79, 81A & 90
Paavali Jumppanen, piano
ONDINE ODE 1290-2D (2 CDs) 71’32 & 47’20

Paavali Jumppanen gives fine performances of this more traditional fare. The interesting booklet notes draw attention to some of the features of these works which trace developments in Beethoven’s compositional style.

PIERRE de la RUE – MISSA NUNCQUA FUE PENA MAYOR
The Brabant Ensemble, Stephen Rice, conductor
HYPERION CDA68150  78’55

This is an enjoyable recording of renaissance choral music from the continent by experienced performers. As well as the Mass which gives the CD its title we also hear Pierre de la Rue’s Salve Regina IV, Magnificat sexti toni and Missa Inviolata.

C.P.E. BACH – THE SOLO KEYBOARD MUSIC, Vol 31
‘FUR KENNER UND LIEBHABER’ SONATAS FROM COLLECTIONS 1 & 2
Miklos Spanyi, clavichord
BIS RECORDS  BIS-2131 73’23

It is no surprise that this prolific, but long neglected, composer’s keyboard output has already filled 30 volumes! Here are seven sonatas of varying lengths (the longest 19’07, the shortest 6’24) played on a 1991 clavichord. Very enjoyable but perhaps a release for the completist collector.

C.P.E. BACH – BURGERCAPITAINSMUSIK 1780
Barockwerk, Hamburg, Ira Hochman, director
CPO 555 016-2  62’57

This is a very interesting release of music written by CPE Bach commissioned by the Civic Captains of Hamburg, a group with great influence on the life of the city, for their annual gala. The commission was in two parts – an oratorio to be presented around noon and a serenata to accompany the evening banquet. CPE Bach composed music for these occasions in 1780 and again in 1783. Here we have the first such offering. The oratorio Hebt an, ihr Chore der Freuden is followed by the serenata Der Trommeln Schlag, der Pfeifen Spiel. A fascinating revival of music for a particular occasion.

Bravura: Vivaldi & Handel
Gabriella Di Laccio, soprano, Musica Antiqua Clio, Fernando Cordella
DRAMA MUSICA DRAMA 001

An exciting mix of the familiar – Rinaldo, Giulio Cesare – and the less so – Vivaldi’s Juditha Triumphans and L’Olimpiade. Garsington Opera showed us just what a fine work this latter one is, and the whole disc bubbles with energy and risky coloratura with which Gabriella Di Laccio has no obvious difficulties.

The Celebrated Distin Family
The Prince Regent’s Band
RESONUS RES 10179

What a wonderful find! This is exactly what we need in the build up to Christmas. Much of the music is familiar – arrangements of Meyerbeer, Donizetti, Verdi and Arne – alongside works by Henry and Theodore Distin with lesser known pieces. The Distin Family blazed a trail across Europe and the USA  thanks to an encounter with Adolphe Sax who introduced them to valved brass and the new saxhorn. I can’t recommend this too highly – it is a gem!

Schoenberg: Gurrelieder
Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra & Chorus, Edward Gardner
CHANDOS CHSA 5172(2)

This recording has such a strong cast it could hardly fail. Alwyn Mellor, Stuart Skelton and James Creswell are in the front rank of Wagner singers which Schoenberg’s work requires, and Edward Gardner draws expressive and moving performances from them and the Bergen forces. Might we get a live performance in this country?

Debussy: Four-Hand Piano Music – 2
Jean-Pierre Armengaud, Olivier Chauzu
NAXOS 8.573463

It is difficult to raise much enthusiasm about this recording – though the playing itself is not at fault. The problem lies in the arrangements which in most cases simply don’t work if one knows the original. I can understand that they may be fun to play but the listener is left yearning for the original.

Chopin & Schumann
Horacio Gutierrez, piano
BRIDGE 9479

The 24 Preludes Op28 in a performance which focuses on the continuity which Chopin intended for the cycle – and how well this works. It is almost like a live performance where one is encouraged to see the work as a whole rather than a series of lollipops – a fate which is all too frequent for Chopin’s Preludes. Schumann’s Fantasie Op17 is a more challenging work but none the less given integrity and emotional truth here.

J S Bach: Works for Lute
Johannes Monno, guitar
HANSSLER HC 16085

The guitar is fine – and these are entertaining pieces throughout – but the lute is a different instrument altogether and there is a sense that the pieces lose something in the translation. However this is a bargain given its twenty-seven pieces across the two discs.

SP & BH

DVDs / CDs October 2016

Britten; The Rape of Lucretia
Glyndebourne Festival Opera
OPUS ARTE OA 1219 D

Britten’s opera was given its premiere at Glyndebourne seventy years ago and this new staging is a tribute to its continuing impact as a great work, as well as to the intimacy and sensitivity of the staging. The modern setting works well and Allen Clayton and Kate Royal are particularly effective as the Chorus who form the link between ourselves and the action. Christine Rice is a vulnerable Lucretia in Fiona Shaw’s intelligent production.

 

Glinka: Ruslan and Lyudmila
Bolshoi Theatre Orchestra and Chorus, Vladimir Jurowski
BELAIR BAC 120

For a work so familiar from its overture it is surprising that it is so rarely staged. This fine new recording, in an evocative and visually impressive production by Dmitri Tcherniakov, goes some way to explain why it might be such a rarity. It is very long. What is more, the score often repeats itself, with soloists given an extra verse or two where fewer may have been more effective. The production is well sung under Vladimir Jurowski and the Wagnerian parallels are enhanced by the staging. Worth following up.

 

Cav & Pag
Royal Opera House, Antonio Pappano
OPUS ARTE OA 1210 D

I really enjoyed this production by Damiano Michieletto. He links the two works together without forcing the narrative lines. In both operas the intermezzi are used to bring us characters from the other opera, most effectively in Pag where we see Santuzza and Mamma Lucia reconciled and turning positively to the birth of the baby. It serves to link the people of the village without forcing them into a single story. Aleksandrs Antonenko is strongly cast as both Turiddu and Canio, but there are no weaknesses in a highly compelling staging, driven from the pit by Antonio Pappano at his most romantic.

 

Antoine-Esprit Blanchard: Magnificat a la Chapelle Royale
Les Passions, Jean-Marc Andrieu
LIGIA Lidi 0202313-16

Jean-Marc Andrieu has been working on the scores of Antoine-Esprit Blanchard for thirty years now and this is the latest of his re-discoveries. Three motets are recorded here – Magnificat, De Profundis and In exitu Israel. In 1738 Blanchard was made music master to the Chapelle Royale, having been born in central France in 1696, and got to Paris by a highly circuitous route. Two of the motets are recorded here for the first time and are given with the professional skill and excitement we have come to expect from the group who brought us such thrilling recordings of Jean Gilles. There is a detailed booklet together with the CD and the full text of the motets.

More details of Les Passions and CD purchase available from www.les-passions.fr

Chopin Mazurkas
Pavel Kolenikov, piano
HYPERION CDA 68137

Pavel Kolenikov was one of the BBC New Generation Artists 2014-16 and this recording adds to the many fine performances he has already given. Elegance is not a word often used of performers today but it certainly suits his approach to Chopin, which has a delicacy, an intimacy which reflects the domestic potential of the works as well as their more obvious place in the concert hall. Let us hope we will hear a lot more from him both on stage and in the recording studio.

Celtic Airs
Barry Douglas, piano with ensemble
CHANDOS CHAN 10934

This might not appear to be an obvious ‘classical’ choice but it is a fascinating cross over. Barry Douglas is joined by Irish flute and penny-whistle, Scottish harp and Shetland fiddle, for a collection of Celtic music. Some of it is played straight and other items are used as the basis for improvisation and embellishment . it is easy on the ear but also reflects a high level of professionalism.

 

Haydn: Sun Quartets
Chiaroscuro Quartet
BIS 2158

I enjoyed Tom Service’s notes in which he is effectively doing himself out of job – arguing that we should not read the notes but simply listen to the music. And one can see what he means for these are delightful renditions of delightful music. Just enjoy!

 

Fritz Wunderlich; Festive Arias
SWR 19026CD

For those of us old enough to remember Fritz Wunderlich this is a wonderful disc of the singer at his best. While the Bach and Schutz items are familiar, it is the recording of ten pieces from Handel’s Messiah which are of particular interest as they are sung in German, which is interestingly challenging for those of us who know it so well in English. The recordings were made between 1955-59 though they do not sound their age.

 

Beethoven: Piano Sonatas
Steven Osborne
HYPERION CDA 68073

The three sonatas included here are the Hammerklavier Op106, the Op101 in A major and Op90 in E minor. For some reason, that is not quite clear, they are presented in reverse order to that in which they were written, even when the liner notes point out how well they work if played as a set of three in correct order! None of this affects the quality of the playing which has both subtlety and clarity of texture throughout. This is the third Beethoven disc from Steven Osborne and we can surely hope for more.

 

J S Bach: Goldberg Variations
Angela Hewitt, piano
HYPERION CDA 68146

This is clearly marked 2015 recording to distinguish it from Angela Hewitt’s first recording in 2000. The work itself, as she tells us in an extended article in the accompanying notes, is an essential part of her musical life and has been with her at key moments. She is particularly concerned at its intimacy and potential to make the most impact where the audience is smallest. Better still, the version we hear is a single take, not a patch-work of edits. That reality shines through in a remarkable performance which gets to the heart of the work, communicating with ease, and with a flow that seems effortless.

BH

THE YOUNG J.S. BACH
Andrew Arthur, Carsen Lund organ, Trinity Hall, Cambridge
PRIORY PRCD 1176 (2CDs) 155’31

This welcome release presents the ‘Neumeister chorales’ in lovely performances to celebrate the 10th anniversary of the inauguration of this organ. Providing added variety this well-structured 2 CD release places a number of other contrasting works to punctuate the collection.

THE COMPLETE ORGAN WORKS OF THOMAS TERTIUS NOBLE  Volume 2
John Scott Whiteley, organ of York Minster
PRIORY PRCD 1129
The second volume of this project includes a number of hymn preludes based on well-known tunes (Melcombe, Dominus regit me, Stracathro, Walsall, Picardy) as well as the Sonata in A and Introduction & Fugue in F minor. The CD opens with Toccata & Fugue in F minor. John Scott Whiteley obviously has a great affinity with this music and uses his experience of this organ to the full.

 

MALCOLM WILLIAMSON ORGAN MUSIC
Tom Winpenny, organ, St John the Evangelist, Duncan Terrace, London
NAXOS 8.571375-76 (2 CDs)  99’22

The music of Malcolm Williamson is ripe for rediscovery as this collection of some of his organ works from the late 1950s to the mid ‘70s shows. This is not a complete survey, with several of the more well-known titles missing. However, what is included is lovingly brought back to life by Tom Winpenny, who is developing his reputation as an advocate of twentieth century repertoire.  Shorter pieces include Epitaths for Edith Sitwell and Elegy-JFK. More lengthy works are the fascinating Peace Pieces, Little Carols of the Saints and Mass of a Medieval Saint. A wonderful release.

 

FITZWILLIAM VIRGINAL BOOK EXCERPTS
Ton Koopman, cembalo/ harpsichord
CAPRICCIO ENCORE C8002
This is an enjoyable collection of a selection of pieces from the Fitzwilliam book. It could serve as an excellent introduction to the delights of the keyboard repertoire of this era or purely as an entertaining listening experience. The recordings are some years old but Ton Koopman’s mastery of the keyboard shines through.

 

STILL, O HIMMEL – Christmas Carols by Joseph Haas & his contemporaries
Muncher Frauenchor & Munchen Madchenchor
directed by Katrin Wende-Ehmer, organist Norbert Duchtei
TYZart CHROMART CLASSICS TXA15070  77’00

This recording of German Christmas carols by the Munich Ladies’ & Girls’ choirs gives an insight into music that was largely unknown to me. The first part of the CD consists of extracts from Haas’ Christmas oratorio, Christnacht, which draws on Bavarian and Tyrolean folk melodies. Alongside this are carols by Rheinberger and Reger, as well as less familiar names including Erna Woll and Christian Lahusen. A welcome alternative for the Christmas season.

 

DICH MARIA HEUT ZU PREISEN – The most beautiful compositions in praise of the Virgin Mary by South German and Italian masters of the 18th & 19th centuries
MECHTHILD KEINDL, soprano, ANNE DUFRESNE, oboe, NORBERT DUCHTEL, organ
TYZart CHROMART CLASSICS TXA15069  71’00

Works by Rheinberger, Reger, Konigsperger and others form an interesting and varied programme.

SP

 

 

August / September CDs

Our apologies that, due to holidays, our reviews are far briefer than usual and in some cases this is simply a note of CDs which we are pleased to recommend.

Schubert: Winterreise
Hermann Prey, baritone; Helmut Deutsch, piano
SWR MUSIC SWR19012CD

I heard Hermann Prey many times at the end of the last century and this recording, which dates from 1987, is a wonderful tribute to his art and sensitivity. Even if you already have a recording (or as in my case – many) this is certainly a valuable addition.

Schubert: Schwanengesang
James Rutherford, baritone; Eugene Asti, piano
BIS 2180 SACD

Better known as a Wagner singer (particularly as Hans Sachs) James Rutherford brings a gentle introspection to many of the songs here. There is always a difficulty for lower voices singing this cycle but they opted simply to put the whole thing down a minor third which maintains the relationship of the songs as they follow on. A convincing approach and most effective.

The Romantic Piano Concerto – 68
Moszkowski Op3; Schulz-Evler, Russian Rhapsody
Ludmil Angelov, piano; BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra, Vladimir Kiradjiev
HYPERION CDA68109

This series seems to run on and on – and here brings us the first recording of Adolf Schulz-Evler’s Russian Rhapsody. Though virtually unknown today this is an interesting curiosity for a composer whose Blue Danube Arabesques still command attention in the concert-hall.

Lehar: Guiditta
Bavarian Radio Chorus; Munich Radio Orchestra; Ulf Schirmer.
CPO 777 749-2

There have been a large number of recordings which originated in radio broadcasts, some of dubious quality. Happily this is among the better versions and – with limited dialogue – the music speaking for itself and often coming happily to life. Lehar deserves some staged performances again! And not just the Merry Widow.

CPE Bach: Cello concertos
Nicolas Altstaedt, cello; Arcangelo, Jonathan Cohen
HYPERION CDA68112

 

Saint-Saens Quartet Op 11
Chausson Quartet Op30
Schubert Ensemble
CHANDOS CHAN 10914

 

Beethoven; Piano Sonatas
Angelia Hewitt
HYPERION CDA68131

No9 in E major, Op14 No1; No19 in G minor, Op49 No1; No20 in G major, Op49 No2; No26 in Eb major les adieux, Op81a

Delius
Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra, Richard Hickox
CHANDOS CHAN 10913 X

A reissue of the recording made in 1995. The Walk to the Paradise Garden; A Dance Rhapsody No1; A Dance Rhapsody No2; In a Summer Garden; North Country Sketches.

Apres un reve; A Faure Recital
Louis Lortie, piano
CHANDOS CHAN 10915

As this is listed as Vol1 we can assume there is more to follow! It includes the Pavane Op50 as well as the suite for Pelleas et Melisande Op80 and is charming throughout.

Brahms: String Quartet Op51 No1; Quintet Op34
Brodsky Quartet, Natacha Kudritskaya, piano
CHANDOS CHAN 10892

 

Berlioz: Romeo & Juliet; Royal Hunt and Storm
BBC Symphony Orchestra & Chorus, Sir Andrew Davis
CHANDOS CHAN 5169(2)

With the exception of Beatrice & Benedict at Glyndebourne this summer it seems a long time since we had any staged Berlioz and this reminds us just how good it is. Romeo & Juliet may not technically be an opera but musically it is in all but name – and surprising that it has not been staged as such. The Royal Hunt and Storm benefits from the massed forces of the BBC Chorus.

Bruckner: Symphonies 0-9
Mario Venzago, conductor, various orchestras.
CPO 555023-2

This set of ten CDs deserves an article to itself rather than this brief notice. Mario Venzago has a unique approach to Bruckner, often making it lighter and more transparent than we are normally used to. He makes a good case for his reading and I certainly enjoyed the approach though accept it may not be to all tastes. If you get a chance to sample it, do so, and be prepared to agree.